Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana
The Original Apizza, Since 1925
The birthplace of New Haven apizza and a 100-year-old icon, where coal-fired brick ovens turn out the famously charred, chewy thin-crust pies — including the original white clam pie. A plain tomato pie (mozzarella is a topping here, the old-school way) is the budget order, and a small feeds two light. Expect a Wooster Street line, and order ahead if you can. Two eat for around $18.
Sally's Apizza
Pepe's Rival Since 1938
Opened by Frank Pepe's nephew Sal a few doors down in 1938, and beloved by everyone from JFK to Sinatra. The pies are restrained — just a whisper of sauce and a dusting of pecorino to let that blistered crust shine — with a cult potato-and-rosemary special worth a detour. Share a classic tomato pie and you're under budget. Two eat for around $18.
Modern Apizza
The Locals' Pick Since 1934
The third of the city's Big Three and, ask around, many New Haveners' actual favorite — partly because the wait beats Wooster Street's, mostly because the dough (from a decades-old starter) and the char are just right. Get the loaded Italian Bomb if you're hungry, or split a plain pie and admire the original prices still painted on the wall. Two eat for around $18.
Zeneli Pizzeria
Naples Comes to Wooster Street
Four brothers from Naples set up on Wooster Street and made their name on impossibly delicate, puffy-edged Neapolitan pizza — a soft, airy counterpoint to the charred apizza next door. They even went to the Capitol to help crown New Haven the country's pizza capital. Split a pie and a salad. Two eat for around $20.
BAR
Brewpub & Mashed-Potato Pizza
An industrial-chic brewpub that doubles as one of New Haven's most fun pizza spots, famous for a mashed-potato-and-bacon pie that has no business being as good as it is, alongside classic red pies and house-brewed beer. A pizza split two ways keeps it cheap — the beer's extra. Two eat for around $18.
One6Three
East Rock Wood-Fired Favorite
A tiny East Rock neighborhood spot with a few tables and counter seats right by the oven, turning out wood-fired pies locals adore — none more than the Fungus Among Us, all sautéed mushrooms, roasted garlic and a whisper of truffle oil. Share one with a salad. Two eat for around $20.
Louis' Lunch
Birthplace of the Hamburger, 1895
The Library of Congress credits this tiny brick lunch counter — family-run since 1895, now the fourth generation — with serving America's first hamburger sandwich. It's still cooked in the original 1898 vertical cast-iron grills and served on white toast with only cheese, onion and tomato. Ask for ketchup at your peril. Two burgers, the cult potato salad and a Foxon Park soda do it. Two eat for around $18.
Mamoun's Falafel
Falafel Institution Since 1971
The New Haven outpost of the legendary Greenwich Village falafel shop — one of the first Middle Eastern restaurants in the country — slinging cheap, from-scratch falafel, shawarma and kebab sandwiches with that famously silky hummus. Two sandwiches and a side of fries do it (and respect the very spicy hot sauce). Two eat for around $16.
Sherkaan Indian Street Food
Indian Street Food by Yale
Right by the Yale Bookstore, Sherkaan reinterprets Central and South Indian street food in giant, shareable portions inside a funky, colorful room — frankie rolls, chaat and rice bowls big enough that two can split a couple of dishes and walk away full. Two eat for around $20.
Claire's Corner Copia
Kosher Vegetarian Since 1975
A New Haven institution on Chapel Street since 1975, this homey counter spot has been doing kosher vegetarian — with a heavy Mexican lean — since long before it was fashionable. Portions are large (salads and soups arrive with bread), and you cannot leave without a slice of the famous Lithuanian coffee cake. Two eat for around $20.
Yorkside Pizza & Restaurant
The Yale-Campus Greek Diner
Smack in the middle of the Yale campus, Greek-owned Yorkside has fed generations of students its glistening Greek-style high-crust pizza (available by the slice, a New Haven rarity) plus gyros, souvlaki and diner classics. Cheap, fast and open when you need it. Two eat for around $18.
Atticus
Bookstore Café Classic
Part bookstore, part bakery-café, Atticus has been a Chapel Street fixture for decades — house-baked breads, soups, salads and sandwiches eaten at a communal counter surrounded by books. Split a sandwich and a soup, add a coffee and a pastry. Two eat for around $18.
💡 Pro tip: All deals are community-verified, and we've linked each spot's official menu where one exists. New Haven apizza is sold by the pie (not the slice, mostly), so the two-under-$20 move is to split a plain tomato or one-topping pie — and the famous Wooster Street spots draw real lines at peak. Hours and prices change, so check before a special trip. If something's expired, flag it on our main directory so we can update it.
These chain deals work anywhere in the country, including New Haven.
Buffalo Wild Wings
Pick 6 — Meal for Two from $19.99
The Pick 6 lets two people build a shared meal — choose six items across wings, tenders, and sides — starting around $19.99. A reliable two-for-$20 play at any BWW. Dine-in or takeout; pricing varies slightly by market.
See all national chain deals →
See All 1,900+ Deals
Browse the full directory — dozens of cities, national chains, updated June 2026.
Browse the Directory